The war against terror involves the height of expensive
technology -- cutting
edge sensors, robotic
warriors, and... pricey aircraft luxury suites? This curious last
addition has come under public scrutiny and is the subject of a major debate.
Over the last three years the Air Force's leadership sought counterterrorism
funding to build "comfort capsules" for its top ranking
officers. These new luxury suites would allow senior officers and
civilian leaders to travel the world in style
and comfort, all on the U.S. taxpayers' bill.
In long email dialogs and budget documents four top generals planned such
minute details as color and style of the carpet and leather chairs for the
suite. Production of the first capsule has already begun and it will
feature two posh rooms. According to the generals, who are defensive
about the efforts, the new capsules are essential to allowing the leadership to
talk, work and rest comfortably in the air.
However, the expensive efforts are not meeting with such glowing praise among
lower ranking officers, among members of Congress, and among the American
public. Many are calling the program a waste of valuable antiterrorism
funds.
Well, each citizen will have to examine the expenditures and form their own
opinions. To consider this, we must look at the rooms in a bit more
detail. The capsules are to be "aesthetically pleasing and furnished
to reflect the rank of the senior leaders using the capsule." Each
features designer furniture -- beds, a couch, a table. Also included are
a 37-inch flat-screen monitor with stereo speakers and a full length mirror, so
the leadership can always be sure they're looking good.
The project has been slowed, to the generals' frustration by Congress being
skeptical about the use of counterterrorism funds for the pet project.
Further the generals numerous demands for upgrades in the suites were also the
subject of some incredulity in Air Force proceedings. Among these
requests were for the color of the leather for the seats and seat belts in the
mobile pallets be changed from brown to Air Force blue and that seat pockets be
added; another was that the color of the table's wood be darkened. These
little changes were expected to carry a little price tag of $68,240.
In total, the project leaders have begged Congress to let it use $16.2M USD in
funds, coming from the resources for the GWOT, or global war on terrorism, on
the project. Congress has refused each time, demanding the funds be spent
on higher priority items.
Nevertheless the Air Force continued planning and construction. Then came
a $331,000 budget overrun last year, thanks in part to the design
changes. This time the Air Force managed to take the money out of the
counterterrorism funds. A senior officer has said that based on inquiries
since, the Air Force has reversed the decision and will be returning the funds
and looking for alternative sources of financing.
The story first came into the public eye thanks to a series of emails delivered
to the Washington Post by nonprofit group Project on Government
Oversight (POGO). They have since been independently authenticated and it
has been revealed that pressure was applied to lower ranking officers to
created "world class" accommodations well beyond the standards of a
regular business-class flight.
In a March 2007 email to a colleague, an officer at the service's Air Mobility
Command said, "I was asked by Gen. [Robert H.] McMahon what it would take
to make the [capsule] . . . a 'world class' piece of equipment. He said
he wanted an assurance . . . that we would be getting a world class item this
week."
The Air Force says that the program dates back to 2006, when Air Force Gen.
Duncan J. McNabb decided that existing accommodations aboard transport aircraft
was good enough airmen and troops, but not good enough for top brass. At
the time General McNabb was Air Mobility commander; he is now the Air Force's
vice chief of staff and has been nominated to be promoted to head of the
military's Transportation Command.
In a complaint letter to Defense Secretary Robert M. Gates, who nominated him,
POGO's Danielle Brian, the group's executive director, asserts that the
capsules have no special communications or work capabilities useful in the war
against terrorism, and are "a gross misuse of millions of taxpayer dollars
that could otherwise be used to train and equip soldiers."